For this you'll want to take your piston with you to Home Depot and find a 4" male that it'll slide through. While the IDs should be identical, the actual parts are manufactured to loose enough tolerances that you need to pick em out by hand. Its kinda like how you can try sleeving 1.5" SDR in 2" sch80 and it can be either an ungodly tight fit or really really loose. Its simply not that precise.